The Local Government (System Improvements) Amendment Act promised to remove voting powers from unelected appointees on council committees.
However, figures supplied by the Ministry for Cities, Environment, Regions and Transport show at least 23 applications for exemptions from the new rules. Only four councils (Dunedin, South Taranaki, Ruapehu and Environment Canterbury) limited their requests to audit and risk-type committees, which can’t regulate or spend ratepayer money.
Taxpayers’ Union Head of Policy James Ross said:
“Voters were promised democracy. But Simon Watts has set up a mechanism to sneak around it with an extremely low benchmark baked into the legislation.
“No one should have a vote on council spending or regulatory decisions unless they are accountable to voters. Councils falling over themselves to put voters second, and screw the democratic scrum, is a disgrace.
“Some councils are trying to take a sledgehammer to the Government’s reforms. Waikato District Council has requested thirteen exemptions, Tauranga City eight, and Southland District six. Selwyn District has gone one step further, asking for exemptions for ‘all committees to which mana whenua representatives are appointed’.
“Watts’ Act effectively undermined Prime Minister Luxon’s commitment to return to the democratic default by including a gaping loophole. Exemptions only need to be ‘necessary or desirable’ for the Local Government Minister to wave them through. Such loose wording could mean anything to anyone.”
“Given that caretaker conventions apply, it would be a constitutional disgrace for Watts to change the status quo and depart from the historic norm that councils are democratically controlled. He should make a public commitment to reject exemptions that undermine democratic accountability and not abuse ministerial discretion.”
The requests for exemptions so far are as follows:
| Council | Committees |
|---|---|
| Ashburton District Council | Audit, Risk and Finance Committee Three Waters Committee Biodiversity Advisory Group Stockwater Transition Working Group |
| Christchurch City Council | Audit and Risk Management Committee Te Hononga Council – Papatipu Rūnanga Committee Ōtākaro Avon River Corridor Regeneration Committee Greater Christchurch Partnership Committee |
| Dunedin City Council | Audit, Risk and Assurance Committee |
| Environment Canterbury | Audit and Risk Committee |
| Gisborne District Council | Audit and Risk Committee Interim Water Management Committee |
| Horowhenua District Council | Risk and Assurance Committee Community Wellbeing Committee |
| Horowhenua District, Palmerston North City and Rangitīkei District Councils (joint application)* | Shareholders’ Committee for Central Districts Water |
| Manawatū District Council | Finance and Performance Committee Manawatū Water Services Committee |
| Matamata-Piako District Council | Te Manawhenua Forum mō Matamata-Piako |
| New Plymouth District Council | Creative Communities Scheme Assessment Committee Finance, Audit and Risk Committee Te Huinga Taumata |
| Northland Regional Council | Kaipara Moana Remediation Joint Committee |
| Porirua City Council | Audit and Risk Committee Chief Executive Employment Committee Te Puna Kōrero Committee |
| Ruapehu District Council | Risk and Assurance Committee |
| Selwyn District Council | Audit and Risk Committee All committees to which mana whenua representatives are appointed Sister Cities Committee |
| Southland District Council | Finance and Assurance Committee Executive Committee Riverton Harbour Subcommittee Te Anau Basin Water Supply Subcommittee Stewart Island/Rakiura Visitor Levy Allocation Subcommittee Great South Joint Shareholder Committee |
| South Taranaki District Council | Risk and Assurance Committee |
| Stratford District Council | Audit and Risk Committee Water Services Committee |
| Taupō District Council | Taupō District Water Services Committee Risk and Assurance Committee Tūrangi Co-Governance Committee |
| Tauranga City Council | Audit and Risk Committee City Future Committee City Delivery Committee Tangata Whenua / Tauranga City Council Committee Wastewater Management Review Committee SmartGrowth Leadership Group Regulatory Hearings Panel Taheke - Bay Waters Joint Committee |
| Waikato District Council | Audit, Risk and Opportunities Committee Development Agreements Committee Meremere Community Committee Pookeno Community Committee Tamahere Community Committee Te Kauwhata Community Committees Future Proof Implementation Committee Hauraki Scheme Subcommittee Waikato Scheme Subcommittee RTC Public Transport Subcommittee Hauraki Gulf Forum Papahua Holiday Camp Management appointments Creative Communities Scheme Assessment Committee |
| Waimate District Council | Audit and Risk Committee Water Services Committee |
| Whakatāne District Council | Finance, Performance and Risk Committee Community Grants and Funding Committee |