The Taxpayers’ Union is calling on the incoming Government to replace politicised council code of conduct processes with recall elections, following the complaint against Dunedin City Councillor Jo Galer.
Taxpayers’ Union Senior Policy Analyst Josh Van Veen said:
“Councillors are elected to challenge decisions and ask uncomfortable questions. They should not have to fear a conduct complaint every time they speak out.”
“We warned last year that vague ‘respect’ rules could suppress legitimate debate. The threat of an investigation alone can silence councillors and weaken scrutiny.”
“Meanwhile, repeated proceedings against fellow Dunedin councillor Benedict Ong highlight how ineffective these processes can be at resolving persistent misconduct. The system risks silencing legitimate criticism while failing to address the behaviour it is supposed to prevent.”
“Simon Watts failed to fix this when he had the opportunity in his System Improvements legislation. The incoming Government and next Local Government Minister must finish the job.”
“Recall elections would put accountability where it belongs: with voters. A petition meeting a clear statutory threshold should trigger a binding recall vote, allowing communities to remove representatives who have lost their confidence.”