Lower Taxes, Less Waste,
More Accountability

Championing Value For Money From Every Tax Dollar

Taxpayer Update: Stop this Bill | Road to Zero | Rego hikes

Dear Supporter,

Government launches assault on "one person, one vote"


The Government has voted for a law change that will end one person one vote democracy in local government, and we have less than a week to have our say on this massive and undemocratic change.

Tamati Coffey's Rotorua District Council (Representation Arrangements) Bill overrides the current Local Electoral Act to mandate that the 22,000 voters on the Māori Roll in Rotorua have the same number of Ward Councillors as the 56,000 voters on the General Roll. This means that the vote of someone on the General Roll in Rotorua will be worth only 58% of the vote of someone on the Māori Roll.

The current law specifies that the number of Māori constituency members should reflect the respective share of the population of those on the Māori roll to the overall roll. But this law change will stop that. 28% of Rotorua residents get 50% of the ward seats and the other 72% only get half the say.

At the Taxpayers’ Union we believe in democracy. It is essential for residents and ratepayers to be able to sack Councils and hold them accountable when they go off the rails, and one person one vote is an essential part of that.

Here's what you can do to stop this Bill

Here's how you can make a submission on the Bill before the 20 April deadline:

The significance of this law change is massive. If they change the law for one Council, it is almost inevitable they will eventually change the law for all Councils, and then even for Parliament. We need people power to stop this law.

Click here to use the submission template.

Revealed: NZTA spends millions promoting Government policy

Recognise these two NZTA / Waka Kotahi ads promoting the Government's "Road to Zero" strategy?

WK ad 2Click here to watch.

WK ad 1Click here to watch.

Together, the ads have cost taxpayers $4.7 million. Production costs alone totalled $1 million per ad.

This is on top of the $2.4 million spent on the infamous 'Safe Limits' ad, highlighted in a recent Taxpayer Update.

Perhaps more concerning than the cost is the content: the ads do no contain any positive road safety or educational messages. Instead, they serve to promote Government policy, warming up New Zealanders for lower speed limits.

We think the ads breach the official Guidelines for Government Advertising which prohibit using taxpayer money to promote a policy agenda so we've written to the Public Service Commission to request an intervention.

Click here to read more.

Motorists, towies, and taxis set to get whacked with higher fees

Waka Kotahi fees

Speaking of NZTA / Waka Kotahi, the agency is currently reviewing its various administration fees.

It is trying to frame its review as a fee "switch", dropping some fees and increasing others, but the overall effect is a tax grab – the agency will collect an extra $79 million from motorists.

Under NZTA's plans, fees will be hiked for:

  • Everyone renewing their vehicle registration

  • Anyone paying road user charges

  • Disabled vehicle users

  • New Taxi and Uber drivers

  • New driving instructors and testing officers

  • New tow truck drivers and vehicle transporters

  • New forklift and roller drivers

  • Restricted license drivers working night shifts or transporting children

Meanwhile, convicted drink drivers and collectors of exotic cars get a discount!

Click here to read more.

You can make your voice heard on these plans by emailing [email protected].

Should tourists have to cover their medical costs?


We'll be glad to see the return of tourists as our borders re-open, but we need to deal with two problems:

Tourists who end up in hospital for non-accident health issues are meant to cover their medical costs, but every year some of them leave the country with unpaid bills. In fact, in a decade they've racked up $600 million in unpaid debts.

And now, with COVID-19 steadily circulating, some tourists will develop symptoms but be reluctant to get tested, lest they have to fork out for seven days of isolation in hotel.

On Tuesday I joined NewstalkZB to argue that compulsory travel insurance for tourists (including COVID cover) would deal to both these issues.

Grant Robertson's ever-growing tax take

Last week Treasury published its Interim Financial Statements for the first 8 months of the financial year, and Grant Robertson will be rubbing his hands.

Despite the continued disruption from Covid-19, Grant Robertson has taken $1.8 billion more in tax revenue than forecast in December's fiscal update.

And the Government has actually spent $1.4 billion less than forecast, giving Grant Robertson a massive allowance for next month's Budget.

All up, the Government has pulled in $7.1 billion in extra tax revenue compared to the same time period a year ago, despite New Zealand's lockdown in August-September.

A major cause of this extra revenue is inflation. High inflation means many Kiwis are getting significant pay rises on paper that don't actually translate to higher buying power. Instead, pay rises are simply pushing workers into higher tax brackets, sending real incomes backwards to the benefit of Grant Robertson.

Stats NZ's latest update had inflation at 5.9%, but we're predicting figures released next week will show inflation has risen to around 7%.

We say Grant Robertson needs to resist the urge of a spending blowout. It's time to pay down debt and provide tax relief for households squeezed by the cost of living.

Ihumātao saga shows co-governance in action

Book of records

Taxpayers forked out $30 million for the land at Ihumātao and gifted it to mana whenua on the basis that housing would be built.

Almost 18 months after Jacinda Ardern and Willie Jackson's big announcement, mana whenua haven’t even agreed on who will be appointed to the group that’s meant to govern the land. A decision on the number of homes built could be years away, and actual construction looks like a pipe dream.

If this is what co-governance looks like in action, we'd hate to see how decisions get made under Three Waters.

(We've set up a live webcam to track housing construction at Ihumātao. Click here to see what's happening.)

Taxpayer Talk: The threat of Fair Pay Agreements, + ACT's view on water and climate change

The Government's Fair Pay Agreements Bill passed its first vote in Parliament last week. The legislation will initiate the largest shake up for employment relations in decades. Jordan sat down with Business NZ CEO Kirk Hope to discuss how Fair Pay Agreements will mean more barriers to employment, less jobs, higher labour costs and no productivity gains. Click here to listen.

The Government is determined to implement Three Waters and introduce a plethora of interventions aimed at climate change. ACT MP Simon Court joined our podcast to discuss Three Waters, and why the Government's climate policies will only cost taxpayers without reducing total emissions. Click here to listen.

You can find all of our Taxpayer Talk episodes on Apple PodcastsSpotifyGoogle Podcasts, or iHeart Radio.

Have a great Easter break,

Louis circle

Louis Houlbrooke
Campaigns Manager
New Zealand Taxpayers' Union


PS. Last week we hosted a special Zoom update on the Three Waters litigation. This weekend we will be sharing a new written update with everyone who has signed our petition to Stop Three Waters.

Media coverage:

Homepaddock  If they can’t build houses

Newstalk ZB  
Louis Houlbrooke: We need to ensure tourists cover their costs

The cycleway that keeps costing money

Sunday Star-Times  
The Ardern govt has achieved close to nothing outside of Covid

The New Zealand Initiative 
Annual Report 2021

Hawkes Bay Today 
Concern for low-income earners over proposed Tararua District rates hike

Award for most incompetent Minister goes to . . .

Heritage Foundation 
The Real Cost of New Zealand’s Dramatic COVID-19 Response

Farm lobby ruptures into open battle as Groundswell attacks established players

Offsetting Behaviour 
Wellington hates economists?

Join Us

Joining the Taxpayers' Union costs only $25 and entitles you to attend our annual conference, AGM and other events.


With your support we can make the Taxpayers' Union a strong voice exposing waste and standing up for Kiwi taxpayers.

Tip Line

Often the best information comes from those inside the public service or local government. We guarantee your anonymity and your privacy.